Location: The State of Jammu and Kashmir
encompasses a mountainous region in the heart of Asia, with borders
touching to both South and Central Asia. Surrounded by Pakistan,
India, China and Afghanistan.
Area: 86,000 square miles, more than
three times the size of the Netherlands, Luxembourg and Belgium
combined. Bigger than 87 member countries of the United Nations.
Population: Estimated 13 million,
including 1.5 million refugees in Pakistan and 0.5 million expatriates
in different parts of the world. Larger than 114 sovereign nations.
Background: Technically, the area is
called The State of Jammu and Kashmir, and has been historically
independent, except in the anarchical conditions of the late 18th
and the first half of the 19th century or when incorporated in
the vast empires set up by the Mauryas (3rd century BC), the Mughals
(16th to 18th centuries) and the British (mid-19th to mid-20th
centuries).
Cause of Dispute: In 1846, the British
colonial rulers of India sold the territory, including its populace
(by a sale deed called the Treaty of Amritsar, in return for a
sum of money) to a Hindu warlod who had no roots there. This warlord
who bought himself into royalty, styled himself as the Maharajah
of Jammu and Kashmir. The acts of brutality during his regime
have left bitter memories, some of which persist to this present
day. Several mosques were closed and occupied by his forces. The
slaughtering of a cow was declared a crime punishable by death.
Between 1925 and 1947 Maharajah Hari Singh continued this policy
of discrimination against the 94 percent Muslim majority. It was
nearly 65 years ago, in 1931, that the people of Kashmir made
their first organised protest against Maharajah Hari Singh's cruelty.
That led to the "Quit Kashmir" campaign against the
Maharajah in 1946, and eventually to the Azad Kashmir movement
which gained momentum a year later.
The first armed encounter between the Maharajah's troops and insurgent
forces occurred in August 1947. At this time, Britain was liquidating
its empire in the subcontinent. Faced with a insurgency of his
people, strengthened by a few hundred civilian volunteers from
Pakistan, Maharajah fled to Jammu on 25th October 1947. In Jammu,
after he ascertained a commitment of military assistance from
the government of India to crush the impending revolution in Kashmir,
he signed the "Instrument of Accession" to India.
Lord Mountbatten conditionally accepted the "Instrument of
Accession" on behalf of the British Crown, and furthermore,
outlined the conditions for official acceptance in a letter dated
27th October 1947:
"In consistence with their policy that in the case of any
(native) state where the issue of accession has been subject of
dispute, the question of accession should be decided in accordance
with the wishes of the people of the state, it is my government's
wish that as soon as law and order have been restored in Kashmir
and her soil cleared of the invaders the question of state's accession
should be settled by a reference to the people."
Then Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, in a speech aired
on AllIndia Radio (2nd November 1947), reaffirmed the Indian
Government's commitment to the right of the Kashmiri people to
determine their own future through a plebiscite:
"We have declared that the fate of Kashmir is ultimately
to be decided by the people. That pledge we have given, and the
Maharajah has supported it, not only to the people of Jammu and
Kashmir, but also to the world. We will not and cannot back out
of it. We are prepared when
peace and law have been established to have a referendum held
under international auspices like the United Nations. We want
it to be a fair and just reference to the people and we shall
accept their verdict."
The Government of India accepted the "Instrument of accession"
conditionally, promising the people of the state and the world
at large that "accession" would be final only after
the wishes of the people of the state were ascertained upon return
of normalcy in the state.
Following this, India moved her forces into Srinagar and a drawnout
fight ensued between Indian forces and the forces of liberation.
The forces of Azad Kashmir successfully resisted India's armed
intervention and liberated onethird of the State. Realising
it could not quell the resistance, India brought the issue to
the United Nations Security Council in January 1948. As the rebel
forces had undoubtedly been joined by volunteers from Pakistan,
India charged Pakistan with having sent "armed raiders"
into the state, and demanded that Pakistan be declared an aggressor
in Kashmir. Furthermore, India demanded that Pakistan stop aiding
freedom fighters, and allowing the transit of tribesmen into the
state.
After acceptance of these demands, coupled with the assurance
that all "raiders" were withdrawn, India would enable
a plebiscite to be held under impartial auspices to decide Kashmir's
future status. In reply, Pakistan charged India with having manoeuvred
the Maharajah's accession through "fraud and violence"
and with collusion with a "discredited" ruler in the
repression of his people. Pakistan's counter complaint was also
coupled with the proposal of a plebiscite under the supervision
and control of the United Nations to settle the dispute.
The Security Council exhaustively discussed the question from
January until April of 1948. It came to the conclusion that it
would be impossible to determine responsibility for the fighting
and futile to blame either side. Since both parties desired that
the question of accession should be decided through an impartial
plebiscite, the Council developed proposals based on the common
ground between them. These were embodied in the resolution of
21st April 1948, envisaging a ceasefire, the withdrawal
of all outside forces from the State, and a plebiscite under the
control of an administrator who would be nominated by the Secretary
General. For negotiating the details of the plan, the Council
constituted a fivemember commission known as "United
Nations Commission for India and Pakistan" (UNCIP) to implement
the resolution.
After the ceasefire, India began efforts to drag the issue
down, and under various pretexts tried to stop the UN resolution
from being implemented. To this day, India pursues the same plan,
and the resolution of 1948 has yet to be realised.
India and Pakistan were at war over Kashmir from 194748
and all early U. N. Security Council Resolutions contained admonishment
for both countries demanding an immediate casefire, which
would be followed by a-UN directed Plebiscite. However, disregarding
that some fifteen resolutions were passed by the United Nations
to this very effect, India and Pakistan again initiated military
skirmish in 1965. At this point, another ceasefire agreement
was effected after United Nations intervention, followed by an
agreement at Tashkent with the good offices of the USSR.
In 1971, India and Pakistan once again became locked in war. Efforts
to bring the latest conflict to an end resulted in the Simla Agreement
and was signed by both India and Pakistan and declared commitment
to reach a "final settlement" on the Kashmir issue,
but this has yet to happen.